NORTH PORT, Fla. — The North Port community is mourning the tragic loss of Tiffany Schiessl, who was killed during an incident at her home on Brassy Loop. Schiessl’s death has shaken friends, family, and neighbors in what authorities have described as an isolated and deeply disturbing event.

The North Port Police Department confirmed that 46-year-old Coy Bothwell has been taken into custody in connection with Schiessl’s death. Bothwell is facing charges of second-degree murder without premeditation. Officials have emphasized that Schiessl and Bothwell were known to each other, and there is no ongoing threat to the public.
The incident began as a burglary call but quickly escalated into a homicide investigation. Officers responded promptly to the scene and began a thorough investigation. Despite the rapid response, Schiessl was pronounced deceased at the residence. Law enforcement continues to examine all aspects of the case, collecting evidence and speaking with witnesses to understand the full circumstances of this tragic event.
Friends and loved ones have expressed their grief, remembering Schiessl as a cherished member of the community. The sudden loss has left a profound impact on those who knew her, highlighting the fragility of life and the shock such acts of violence can bring to a community.
Chief Garrison commended the swift action of the Criminal Investigations Division and the Crime Scene Unit, stating, “I’m incredibly proud of the dedication shown by our team. Because of their hard work and commitment, this individual is behind bars tonight.” Authorities have assured the public that the investigation remains active and that justice will be pursued for Schiessl’s death.
Community members are encouraged to support one another during this difficult time and to remain vigilant in reporting any information that could assist investigators. The North Port Police Department continues to work diligently to provide answers to the family and to ensure the safety of the community as the investigation progresses.
Tiffany Schiessl’s passing is a somber reminder of the unpredictability of life, and her family and community are left to grieve a heartbreaking loss while hoping for justice and closure.